Home »Forum»Feedback and Suggestions»Choosing neither 'maj' nor 'min'

Choosing neither 'maj' nor 'min'

posted on #1
User Avatar Member
Posts: 12
Joined: 23.06.17
After uploading a track, I noticed that if Key is chosen (let's say, A), but major or minor tonality is not, the Key does not show as well. But, what if song is neither minor or major?

I.e. it ends on power chord (1st-5th-8th) without any 3d played to determine the exact mode, but's it is an A power chord for sure.
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC73JG5IfzJ45osSRp5Kbpbg?sub_confirmation=1
posted on #2
User Avatar
Moderator
Posts: 391
Joined: 14.02.18
Good question wishnewsky, and I was thinking about the same lately - what if you're using a jazz (or church) scale like D Phrygian dominant (the "oriental" one) or such?

For easier ones like (as an example) "Scarborough Fair" which is in D Dorian, you could simply write that in C major which has all the same keys. But my example from above? Twists my brain a bit to be honest... :D
posted on #3
User Avatar Member
Posts: 12
Joined: 23.06.17
wjl


Exactly! Or a wholetone scale, as another example.

Also, some songs provide to an improviser a freedom of choice between scales, including not only neither min nor maj, but also both of those, offering the really good practice choice to the next guy.
posted on #4
User Avatar Member
Posts: 12
Joined: 23.06.17
For instance, there is a song with

1) Bass played by member1
and
2) Drums played by member2

In this setup, the song can not have a major or minor key information _yet_, and will be determined by a guitarist or keyboardist, or any other member3.

Bass player, for example, knows that he played in G, but did not define the mood of the song. After a guitar player (member3) plays his part, the song can turn to be in Gmajor _OR_ in Gminor.
Or both(!) -- in different remixes.

You can say: oh, just use your ears or tuner then to define the notes that were played!
Okay, but what if the main/first/last (not root!) bass note, of the track example above is in G, but the song is actually in some variant of C, also yet undefined? That can easily happen, be valid, and make a beautiful track/song afterwards.
In this case, although a bassline does not state it by itself, bassist can provide the info for further remixers that the song is actually in G. Which [scale of] G though -- to be defined by next creative person.
Edited by wishnewsky on November 26 2020 03:00
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC73JG5IfzJ45osSRp5Kbpbg?sub_confirmation=1
wikiloops online jamsessions are brought to you with friendly support by:
KMstar from United States

"It is amazing having friends from around the planet to work on music with. The most fun a muscian can have on the internet."

wikiloops uses Cookies and processes data in compliance with the GDPR,
as stated in our data privacy policy ..